Under what circumstances can a successful claim for winding up a company be made?

A successful claim for winding up a company can be made when the company was formed for an illegal purpose. This means that if the foundational aspects of the company violate the law or public policy, a court can order the company to be dissolved. Such circumstances indicate that the company’s existence is not legitimate, as it operates outside of legal frameworks and does not contribute positively to the marketplace or society.

In contrast, a solid business plan, profitability, and good management do not provide grounds for winding up a company. These attributes may suggest that the company is stable and performing well, thus they would typically not warrant a claim for winding up. Companies that are profitable or well-managed are generally seen as valuable contributions to the economy, and there would be no legal basis for dissolving such entities under ordinary business conditions.